Fastest Pin
| Wrestler |
Season |
Time of the Fall (seconds) |
| Wayne Snyder |
1999-00 |
6 |
| Tad Treaster |
2009-10 |
6 |
| Derek Hambright |
2005-06 |
7 |
| Dave Hart |
1987-88 |
8 |
| Donnie Smith |
1995-96 |
8 |
| Adam Barrick |
2012-13 |
8 |
| Toby Stoner |
1994-95 |
9 |
| Garry Price |
2001-02 |
9 |
| Danny Sheaffer |
2005-06 |
9 |
| Chris Harbert |
2006-07 |
9 |
| Matt McMullen |
1994-95 |
10 |
| Matt McMullen |
1993-94 |
11 |
| Matt Imes |
1995-96 |
11 |
| Eddie Smith |
1995-96 |
11 |
| Zach Bomberger |
1998-99 |
11 |
| Gianni DiFabio |
1999-00 |
11 |
| Philip Bomberger |
2000-01 |
11 |
| Jeff Hare |
2004-05 |
11 |
| Alex Smith |
2007-08 |
11 |
| Zach Beitz |
2009-10 |
11 |